First Verdict in J&J DePuy Hip Implant Trials: $8.3 Million

Posted By Craig McClellan || Mar 11, 2013

The verdict is in: A California jury has awarded $8.3 million to the plaintiff in the first Johnson & Johnson DePuy hip implant case to make it to trial. The jury found that the ASR metal-on-metal hip implant was negligently designed and that the defective design caused injury. It did not, however, award punitive damages since it believed that DePuy took steps to warn of the risks of the hip implants.

This is the first of thousands of hip implant cases against Johnson & Johnson. The second trial began today in Chicago. While personal injury courts do not have to award the same amount of money to each plaintiff with similar injuries, these beginning trials will set the stage for future verdicts.

In fact, we may be able to expect even larger verdicts. The plaintiff in the California DePuy hip implant case had many other illnesses, including diabetes, cancer and heart disease. A healthier plaintiff may have an easier time convincing the jury that the implant caused serious injuries. Furthermore, there is evidence that Johnson & Johnson knew about problems with the ASR metal-on-metal hip implant long before the company recalled it.

During the California hip implant trial, the plaintiff's legal team unearthed documents from consulting surgeons that recommended that Johnson & Johnson stop marketing the DePuy hip implants. There was also a study out of Australia showing that 44 percent of the implants failed within seven years. This kind of information, put into the right jurors' hands, could lead not only to a large general damage award but also punitive damages against Johnson & Johnson and DePuy.

If you have been injured by a DePuy hip implant, there may still be time to bring a lawsuit to recover compensation for your injuries. Learn more by visiting our page on the DePuy hip replacement recall.

Blog Home


  • “We will NEVER forget what you did for us Craig. We are FOREVER GRATEFUL.”

    - K.V.

  • “It was a real honor to preside over a case with you as counsel. In my mind you represent all that is good in our profession.”

    - Judge J.

  • “I just wanted to thank you for your efforts on [Pam’s] behalf, your skills, and your heart. You are not just a lawyer in what you do, you are a master of your profession. And I hope you are passing your mastery to others who may stand in on behalf of the weak or the helpless. It is an honorable effort and a world of mercy. I saw the extreme and extended dedication you put forth yield the best possible results on [Pam’s] behalf.”

    - Juror

  • “We could not be happier with the McCllelan Law Firm team! My husband and I were referred to Craig McCllelan by one of his peers. We had a very sensitive medical malpractice case that we were hesitant to even pursue. Craig and his team sat down and walked us through the entire process giving us their honest opinion and options. We felt very comfortable with the process and completely relieved by the end of the first meeting, so we decided to proceed. It is three years later and we couldn't be happier that we did. Craig, Connor, and his team made the entire experience so easy and smooth. They were always available no matter how small our question or concern. I swear they work 24/7! And most importantly, we knew that they truly cared about us and the outcome. They fought for our family and have given us the piece of mind that our son's healthcare will always be covered. It is truly the greatest gift and we will forever be in their debt!”

    - S.P.

  • “Having had the high privilege of presiding over a number of cases involving national counsel, I want you to know you’re one of the very best [...]. You and those with you were outstanding ambassadors for our profession and once again made me most proud to be a part of our legal community.”

View More

Our Awards & Accolades