911 Dispatcher May Have Given Faulty Instructions

Posted By The McClellan Law Firm || Jan 15, 2015

A 911 dispatcher in San Diego may have given questionable medical instructions, local news reports.

The accident occurred when a motorcycle struck a pedestrian, amputating his leg. A bystander used his belt as a tourniquet in an attempt to save the man's life, following first-aid training he received in the Navy.

"I put the belt around his leg and stopped the bleeding," said the man. "It's been bothering me because I thought I did the right thing by putting the tourniquet on, and when I was told to take it off…yeah, it's been bothering me."

The man's girlfriend was at the scene of the accident and placed the 911 call. In it, the dispatcher instructed them to remove the belt. After the man followed these instructions, the victim became unconscious and later died.

The man said, "But because they said to take [the belt] off, I took it off…and I didn't' agree with that."

San Diego Fire Chief Response

The San Diego Fire Chief issued a statement to local news sources, indicating that the fire department was aware of the issue. The San Diego Fire-Rescue Department is currently reviewing this case.

"I have confidence in the ability of our dispatcher to handle emergencies efficiently," said the fire chief, "…and I want the public to be assured you can have that same confidence."

What are the legal implications?

Although this case is still under investigation, it raises an interesting question: Are 911 dispatchers legally liable for deaths and injuries?

In 2010, a lawsuit alleged that multiple San Francisco dispatchers failed to provide proper emergency services. In the suit, plaintiff's attributed the poor services to maladministration on the part of the San Francisco Department of Emergency Management.

In 2012, the LA Times reported that Los Angeles Fire Department wasted time instructing callers to start CPR on accident and crime victims. The article also stated that "speed is everything," when it comes to CPR, and delayed first-aid can lead to death.

San Diego Wrongful Death Lawsuits

At the McClellan Law Firm, we provide caring legal guidance and advocacy for families who lost someone they love to wrongful death. If you believe that your loved one's death was caused by the carelessness or negligence of another, speak with an attorney from our law firm today.

We offer free consultations. Start yours now.

Blog Home


  • “We could not be happier with the McCllelan Law Firm team! My husband and I were referred to Craig McCllelan by one of his peers. We had a very sensitive medical malpractice case that we were hesitant to even pursue. Craig and his team sat down and walked us through the entire process giving us their honest opinion and options. We felt very comfortable with the process and completely relieved by the end of the first meeting, so we decided to proceed. It is three years later and we couldn't be happier that we did. Craig, Connor, and his team made the entire experience so easy and smooth. They were always available no matter how small our question or concern. I swear they work 24/7! And most importantly, we knew that they truly cared about us and the outcome. They fought for our family and have given us the piece of mind that our son's healthcare will always be covered. It is truly the greatest gift and we will forever be in their debt!”

    - S.P.

  • “We wouldn’t be here, in this moment of life without the kindness and professionalism of you all and how you went to bat for us! Eternally grateful!”

    - A.K.

  • “Immediately after our interview we knew without question that no matter how steep the mountain, win or lose, we had found the right person—Craig McClellan, Esq.—[…] We felt a profound sense of peacefulness whenever we came into the office, and we knew that you were protecting our interests at all time.”

    - G.P.

  • “It was a real honor to preside over a case with you as counsel. In my mind you represent all that is good in our profession.”

    - Judge J.

  • “Your appearance on the nation-wide broadcast of ‘60 Minutes’ was a public service in which all San Diego has reason to take great pride. To integrity—you have added public service and again elevated my opinion of the legal profession.”

    - Juror

View More

Our Awards & Accolades