Continued: Are Doctors Responsible for Helping Take the Car Keys Away from Aging Drivers?

Posted By Craig McClellan || Oct 12, 2012

In our last blog post, we raised the question about whether (and when) doctors are responsible for reporting concerns about an aging patient's ability to drive.

In 2010, at a national Transportation Safety Board hearing on aging drivers, a doctor with the medical advisory board for the Maryland Motor Vehicle Administration testified that doctors in most states are often not aware whether they even have any obligation to report patient's abilities to the local DMV.

According to the Los Angeles Times, as of 2011, only seven states had mandatory reporting requirements for doctors. And several states have loosened previous reporting requirements at the concern that if older individuals thought their doctors could take away their driver's licenses they would avoid seeking medical care.

In California, the law says that doctors must report patients that have "disorders characterized by lapses of consciousness" to local health authorities, who then report to the California Department of Motor Vehicles. Such disorders would include things like Alzheimer's and dementia, but the law leaves the definition open-ended so that doctors can use their own judgment as to whether a patient is still capable of driving.

In the case of the 85-year-old woman who caused a car accident that killed her boyfriend, it is not entirely clear whether the doctor should have reported the woman to the health board. Even though she had been diagnosed with dementia, it appeared that symptoms had not yet affected much of her daily life. Her own daughter was not even aware that her mother had been diagnosed.

The number of drivers over 65 is expected to reach 57 million by 2030 - that is almost twice as many older drivers on the road than in 2007, according to the LA Times. And federal report released in 2007 found that drivers aged 75 or older have a higher chance of being involved in a fatal crash. Statistics such as these do no bear well for the future safety of motorists.

So the question remains, who should be monitoring drivers as they age? In California there is a law that requires all drivers older than 70 to renew their driver's licenses in person, but their licenses, once renewed, are still good for four years. And a lot can change in one's health over the course of four years. Should the family intervene and take away the keys? Is the onerous on one's physician? Does the sole responsibility fall to the DMV?

If you have an aging loved one, what will you do?

Categories: Car Accidents
Blog Home

Testimonials

  • “Your appearance on the nation-wide broadcast of ‘60 Minutes’ was a public service in which all San Diego has reason to take great pride. To integrity—you have added public service and again elevated my opinion of the legal profession.”

    - Juror

  • “Immediately after our interview we knew without question that no matter how steep the mountain, win or lose, we had found the right person—Craig McClellan, Esq.—[…] We felt a profound sense of peacefulness whenever we came into the office, and we knew that you were protecting our interests at all time.”

    - G.P.

  • “I just wanted to thank you for your efforts on [Pam’s] behalf, your skills, and your heart. You are not just a lawyer in what you do, you are a master of your profession. And I hope you are passing your mastery to others who may stand in on behalf of the weak or the helpless. It is an honorable effort and a world of mercy. I saw the extreme and extended dedication you put forth yield the best possible results on [Pam’s] behalf.”

    - Juror

  • “We wouldn’t be here, in this moment of life without the kindness and professionalism of you all and how you went to bat for us! Eternally grateful!”

    - A.K.

  • “Having had the high privilege of presiding over a number of cases involving national counsel, I want you to know you’re one of the very best [...]. You and those with you were outstanding ambassadors for our profession and once again made me most proud to be a part of our legal community.”

View More

Our Awards & Accolades